
From Fire to Symbols II: Chomsky's Leap vs. Gradualist Evolution
About this event
Last time, in Part 1 of From Fire to Symbols, we used Peirce's icon, index and symbol to ask how our ancestors moved from pointing at the world to representing it. This time we take on one of the biggest debates in the field: did language arrive all at once, or did it build up slowly over a million years or more? In this installment of Fire, Cells, and Circuits, we'll set Noam Chomsky's view that language appeared suddenly, in a single evolutionary leap, against gradualist accounts like Barham and Everett's "Semiotics and the Origin of Language in the Lower Palaeolithic," which traces a slow build of symbolic ability starting with Homo erectus. Some questions we'll explore: • Is the core of language a single innate capacity that appeared suddenly, or a set of skills that grew step by step? • What would count as evidence for one view over the other, in fossils, tools or genes? • Could Homo erectus have had some form of language, even without full grammar? • How do Peirce's icons, indexes and symbols fit each story? • Does it matter whether language came before or after complex thought? You don't need to have attended Part 1 to join. Part 3 will turn to tool-making and symbols. Newcomers are always welcome, and we aim for open, respectful conversation. This is an online event. The link will be shared here before the event.
Questions & comments
Ask the host anything — replies are visible to everyone.
—