
20th Century Ethics (Sess 8) - Onora O'Neill, Having Principle
About this event
This Meetup is the eighth in our series on 20th Century Ethics. For 2026 we have been partaking in a series of sessions focused on 20th Century Ethics. The series builds progressively over the course of the year, but individual sessions can be explored independently. The goals of the series are to a) move beyond the ‘greatest hits’ of historical philosophical works into more contemporary 20th Century debates, b) create a landscape of the diverse traditions in phenomenology, virtue ethics, critical theory, and neo-Kantianism, c) explore modern issues of identity, communication, justice, and animal rights, and d) stage opportunities to contrast different thinkers critically. While the content is advanced, the format and discussion style still affords individuals new to these works and, indeed, new to philosophy in general an excellent opportunity to learn and discuss in structured discussion-based environment. The series will include • (Jan/26) Immanuel Kant – a foundational ‘grounding’ for the series • (Feb&Mar/26) Max Scheler – critique of Kant’s formalism with an emphasis on value theory. • (Apr/26) Paul Ricoeur – identity and ethical responsibility with a focus on selfhood and justice. • (May/26) Juergen Habermas – socially embedded ethics. • (June/26) Alasdair MacIntyre – challenges Kantian universality with Aristotelian virtues ethics. • (July/26) Phillippa Foot – naturalistic virtue ethics • (Aug/26)Onora O’Neill – global justice and bioethics. • Christine Korsgaard – moral norms and an argument for contemporary Kantian Ethics. • Epilogue for the series – a comparative look at the threads of autonomy, responsibility, virtue and discourse in a comparative roundtable. In Session 8, “Having Principles”, we will continue our journey into 20th century ethics by considering Onora O’Neill’s work Acting on Principle. The work is a reconstruction of Kantian ethics that centers on intelligible action, principled agency, and obligations rather than rights and duties. She argues that ethical reasoning is fundamentally about acting on maxims that can be made publicly intelligible and universally adoptable, and develops a method for identifying morally relevant descriptions of action so that the Categorical Imperative can genuinely guide real agents. Her work, while built on the foundations of Kant’s theory, demonstrates a vulnerability of the theory of right. O’Neill recognizes that Kantian ethics is not ideal theory. Real agents, agents in the world, deal with incomplete information, conflicting obligations, institutional constraints, and partial compliance, to name a few external contigencies. She argues that principled reasoning still can guide action under this facticity, and that Kantian ethics is uniquely suited to non-ideal contexts because it focuses on intelligible commitments. For this Meetup I will be using the edition published in 2013. Below is the recommended reading for the discussion: • Intro to the Second Edition \~35 pages • Ch 1: Principles of Action \~18 pages • Ch 2: The Problem of Relevant Act Descriptions \~30 pages • Ch 3: A Solution to the Problem… \~8 pages • Ch 5: Applying the Categorical Imperative \~35 pages A few questions to consider: 1. O’Neill treats universalization as a test of intelligibility rather than abstraction. Does this make Kantian ethics more plausible? Or, does it erode Kant’s model? 2. How does her view relate to Habermas’s discourse ethics, where justification is intersubjective rather than principled? 3. Is her account of non-ideal reasoning compatible with Foot’s naturalism or MacIntyre’s practice-based ethics? In 2026 we will begin recording the sessions to create an archive summarization of sessions. I am truly excited about 2026 and hope that you will participate in the series and help make it a fulfilling experience for all of the participants. Hope to see you at the session.
This event has ended.
How was it?
Reviews
This event has finished — be the first to review it!
Questions & comments
Ask the host anything — replies are visible to everyone.
—